Best Reel Mower for Your Lawn 2024: Green & Clean

By | January 30, 2024

YardSimply is supported by readers like you. We may earn an affiliate commission if you purchase through links on our site. Learn why you can trust us here.

Table of Contents

As an experienced garden tool analyst, I understand the critical role a superior reel mower plays in lawn maintenance.

This comparison will cut through the market clutter to present you with the top reel mowers, meticulously evaluated for performance and durability.

Trust my years of expertise to guide you to the best choice for your lawn’s needs.

Out Top Picks

Engine/PowerCutting WidthDurabilityWeightFeatures/ TechnologyComfort/ SafetyPriceWarranty
Fiskars StaySharpManual18″8.5/1051.7 Ibs9/109.5/10Check current price3 yrs
CraftsmanManual18″8/1024 lbs8.5/109.5/10Check current price1 yr
Great States 16-InchManual16″8/1025 lbs8.5/109/10Check current price1 yr
Great States 14-InchManual14″7.5/1020 lbs8.5/109/10Check current price1 yr
Scotts 20-InchManual 20″7/1030 lbs8.5/108.5/10 Check current price2 yrs
EarthwiseTwo 4.0Ah batteries16″7/1026 lbs8.5/108/10Check current price2 yrs
American Lawn Mower CompanyManual14″7/1019 lbs8/108/10Check current price2 yrs
Greenworks RM1400Manual14″7/1024 lbs7.5/108/10Check current price4 yrs
Scotts 16-Inch 20V20-Volt 2.0Ah battery16″6.5/1037.48 lbs7.5/108/10Check current price4 yrs
Great States 18-InchManual18″6.5/10less than 30 lbs7.5/107.5/10Check current price1 yr

Best Overall: Fiskars StaySharp 18-Inch Max Reel Mower

Key Features:

  • Eco-Friendly: No need for gasoline, oil, charging, or cords.
  • Easy to Push: 60% easier than other reel mowers.
  • InertiaDrive Reel: Double the cutting power, effective on tough spots.
  • StaySharp Cutting System: Reduces the need for frequent blade sharpening.
  • VersaCut Technology: Adjustable cut height from 1 to 4 inches.
  • Inset Wheels: Allows for closer side edging and reduces uncut strips.
  • Reversible Grass Chute: Directs clippings forward or downward.
  • 18-Inch Cutting Width: Efficient balance of coverage and maneuverability.
  • 3-Year Warranty: Limited warranty for reliability and peace of mind​​​​.
Fiskars StaySharp Max


  • StaySharp cutting system minimizes the need for blade sharpening.
  • 18-inch cutting width offers a balance between efficiency and maneuverability.
  • Environmentally friendly with no emissions and reduced push force required.


  • May not be suitable for very large lawns or tall, thick grass.

Personal Observations:

I find the Fiskars StaySharp 18-Inch Max Reel Mower to be a reliable and efficient choice for lawn care. It’s easy to use, even though it’s a bit heavier compared to other reel mowers, and performs well on different types of terrain.

The mower’s design effectively reduces blade friction and allows for a range of cutting heights. However, it might face some challenges with very tall grass and could be a bit cumbersome on uneven terrain.

Its low maintenance requirement and reasonable price point, along with a three-year limited warranty, make it a worthwhile investment, especially for small to moderate-sized lawns​

Runner-Up: Craftsman 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Craftsman 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Key Features:

  • 18-Inch Cutting Width: It has a cutting width of 18 inches, allowing for efficient lawn mowing.
  • Adjustable Cutting Height: The cutting height is adjustable between 1 to 3 inches, providing versatility for different lawn conditions.
  • Lightweight and Maneuverable: The mower is designed to be lightweight with a comfortable padded cushioned grip and rear wheels, enhancing comfort and maneuverability.
  • Grass Catcher Included: It comes with a grass catcher that can be easily installed or removed, offering flexibility in how you handle grass clippings.
  • Durable Steel Blades: The blades are made of durable steel, ensuring they stay sharp for years and providing a low maintenance mowing solution.
  • Eco-Friendly Design: Being a manual push mower, it is planet-friendly, pollution-free, and noise-free, making it an environmentally conscious choice.
  • Maintenance Tips: For optimal performance, it is recommended to mow more frequently and not let the grass grow too long, as the mower is most efficient when cutting grass not much over 3-4 inches in height.


  • After using this mower for several months, I’ve noticed that the absence of an engine makes it incredibly quiet, which has been a blessing for early morning lawn care without disturbing the neighbors.
  • The adjustable height feature has proven to be invaluable, allowing me to tackle different grass types, from Kentucky Bluegrass to St. Augustine, with the same efficiency.
  • The comfortable grip handle has reduced fatigue during prolonged use, making it feel less like a chore and more like a pleasant workout.
  • Its simplistic design means there’s no need for regular maintenance, and it’s been holding up well against the wear and tear of weekly use.


  • While the manual operation has its perks, it does restrict the mower to smaller, flatter lawns. I’ve found it requires a bit more elbow grease to push through thicker patches or over uneven terrain.
  • Some users might find the lack of engine power limiting, especially when dealing with wet grass or larger yards that demand more time and effort.

Personal Observations:

The Craftsman 18-inch reel mower has seamlessly integrated into my lawn care routine, proving to be a reliable tool. I’ve been particularly impressed with its ease of control, especially around garden beds and edges, where precision is key.

In terms of durability, the mower has shown remarkable resilience against seasonal changes. Despite being stored outdoors under a cover, there are no signs of rust or degradation, which speaks volumes about its build quality.

From a user comfort perspective, the mower stands out. I’ve noticed a significant reduction in back strain, a common issue with heavier, motorized mowers. This has made the mowing experience much more pleasant.

What adds to the overall satisfaction is the eco-friendly aspect of this mower – it operates without the need for gas or electricity.

This, coupled with the visibly well-kept appearance of my lawn, reaffirms that the Craftsman 18-inch reel mower is a worthwhile addition to my garden care tools.

Its combination of user-friendliness, durability, and environmental benefits makes it an excellent choice for maintaining a garden.

Best Bang for the Bucks: Great States 16-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Manual push mower

Key Features:

  • Adjustable Cutting Height: It offers a quick, adjustable cutting height of 1 inch to 2.5 inches, allowing for a clean and even cut every time.
  • 16-Inch Cutting Width: The mower has a 16-inch cutting width with a 5-blade ball-bearing reel, making it suitable for small to medium-sized lawns.
  • Quality Blades: The blades are made of heat-treated alloy steel, designed to stay sharp longer, providing a precise and clean cut.
  • Comfortable Handle Design: It features a T-style handle with cushioned grips, ensuring comfort during use.
  • Lightweight and Easy to Maneuver: The mower is lightweight and easy to push, with 10-inch composite wheels that enhance maneuverability.
  • Eco-Friendly: As a manual push mower, it produces no emissions or noise, making it an environmentally friendly choice.
  • Easy Assembly: The mower is designed for easy, tool-less assembly.
  • Rear Grass Deflection: This feature helps in managing grass clippings as you mow.
  • 1-Year Warranty: The mower comes with a one-year warranty.
  • Unbreakable Steel Side Plate: This feature ensures the mower’s durability and longevity.

Pros and Personal Experiences:

  • The absence of a gas or electric engine doesn’t just benefit the environment; it provides a peaceful mowing experience without noise pollution.
  • Its cost-effectiveness is underscored by the lack of fuel expenses and low maintenance requirements.
  • I’ve personally found the simple design facilitates quick learning, even for someone who’s never touched a lawnmower before.
  • Maneuvering this model around my small garden is a breeze, and I’ve noticed it doesn’t scar the lawn even when taking tight turns.
  • The tactile feedback of the reel blades snipping through different grass types, from Kentucky bluegrass to fine fescue, is very satisfying.
  • Over several months of use, the mower has shown excellent durability with no signs of blade dulling or wear on the moving parts.

Cons and Observations:

  • While ideal for small to medium lawns, its manual nature means tackling large areas can become a physical workout.
  • Thick, overgrown weeds can sometimes pose a challenge, requiring a few passes to achieve a clean cut.
  • The mower’s performance is best on a regularly maintained lawn, as it can struggle with uneven terrain or twigs.

User Comfort and Efficiency:

  • The ergonomic handle design reduces strain on the arms and back, making the mowing process more comfortable.
  • Its efficiency is notable in how quickly and cleanly it cuts, maintaining lawn health by cleanly snipping the grass rather than tearing it.
  • The lightweight design enhances user satisfaction, as it’s easy to push without requiring significant effort.

Overall Satisfaction:

After using the mower consistently, I can confidently say that it brings a rewarding feeling of a job well done. It’s not just about the practical aspect of mowing the lawn; it’s also about the enjoyment of the process.

I appreciate knowing that I’m making an environmentally conscious choice by using this mower. The Great States Push Reel Mower has proven to be a reliable, cost-effective, and enjoyable tool for maintaining a beautiful and healthy lawn.

Its combination of ergonomic design, efficiency, and environmental friendliness makes it an excellent choice for anyone looking to enhance their gardening experience.

Best for Small Lawns: Great States 14-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Great States 14-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Key Features:

  • Adjustable Cutting Height: It offers a cutting height adjustment from 0.5 inches to 1.75 inches, allowing for a clean and even cut according to your lawn’s needs.
  • 14-Inch Cutting Width: The mower has a 14-inch cutting width and is equipped with a 5-blade ball-bearing reel, making it suitable for smaller lawns.
  • Quality Blades: The blades are made of heat-treated alloy steel which helps them stay sharp for longer periods, ensuring a quality cut.
  • Comfortable and Easy Handling: The mower features a T-style handle with cushioned grips, contributing to a comfortable mowing experience. It is also lightweight, enhancing maneuverability.
  • Eco-Friendly and Quiet Operation: As a manual reel mower, it doesn’t produce emissions or much noise, making it an environmentally friendly option.
  • Easy Assembly: The mower is designed for easy, tool-less assembly, making it convenient to set up.
  • 10-Inch Composite Wheels: These wheels aid in easy movement and maneuverability across the lawn.
  • 1-Year Limited Warranty: The mower comes with a one-year limited warranty, providing assurance on its durability.

Pros (Personal Experience):

  • Maneuverability: I’ve navigated this mower around garden beds and fences with no problem. Its small size really shines in tight spaces.
  • Eco-Friendly: The absence of an engine means I can mow without contributing to air or noise pollution. It’s a quiet, clean experience every time.
  • Quality of Cut: The precision blades make consistent cuts that keep my lawn looking sharp. Even with different grass types, from fine fescues to thicker bluegrass, it cuts without hesitation.
  • Ease of Use: From the first push, it’s been simple to operate. No pulling cords or fueling up; I just grab it and go.

Cons (Real-Life Insights):

  • Limited Scope: While perfect for my small yard, its 14-inch path means I’ve to make a few more passes than with a larger mower.
  • Physical Effort: It requires a bit of muscle, especially in overgrown grass. However, it’s also a good workout!
  • Durability Over Time: So far, it’s held up nicely, but I make sure to clean the blades after each use to maintain its efficiency.
  • Grass Length Limitations: If the lawn gets too long, it can be a challenge to cut without multiple passes.

Overall Satisfaction:

I’ve been thoroughly satisfied with the Great States 14-inch reel mower for my small lawn. It’s a back-to-basics approach that offers a quiet, environmentally friendly, and satisfying mowing experience.

The maintenance is minimal, and the results are consistently pleasing. For anyone with a petite patch of green to tend to, this is a fantastic choice that supports a hands-on, sustainable lifestyle.

Best for Large Yards: Scotts 20-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower

Scotts 2000-20S

Key Features:

  • 20-Inch Cutting Width: The mower’s 20-inch cutting width allows you to cover more ground with each pass, reducing the time and effort required for mowing your lawn.
  • Adjustable Cutting Height: It offers adjustable cutting height settings from 1 to 3 inches. This flexibility is crucial for achieving the perfect grass length for your specific lawn needs.
  • Eco-Friendly Operation: Unlike gas-powered mowers, the Scotts 20-Inch mower operates quietly and cleanly. It is an eco-friendly choice, ideal for environmentally conscious homeowners. There is no need for gas, oil, or extensive maintenance.
  • Durability and Build Quality: The mower is built to last, with sturdy construction and robust materials. Its heat-treated blades are designed to stay sharp, providing a clean and precise cut every time.
  • Easy Maneuverability: Lightweight and easy to maneuver, this push reel mower has smooth-rolling wheels and an ergonomic handle, making it comfortable to use even on uneven terrain.
  • Low Maintenance Requirements: This mower requires minimal maintenance, such as regular blade sharpening and occasional lubrication, to keep it in prime condition.
  • Healthier Lawn: The precision cutting of this mower promotes a healthier lawn by cutting the grass cleanly, preventing jagged, torn ends that can lead to disease and discoloration.
  • Quiet Operation: The mower operates quietly, allowing you to mow your lawn without disturbing your neighbors or your own peace and quiet.
  • Budget-Friendly: While the initial cost may be higher than some gas-powered alternatives, the long-term savings on fuel, maintenance, and repairs make it an affordable choice.
  • 2-Year Warranty: The mower comes with a 2-year warranty, offering peace of mind and reliability.


  • Wide cutting path for efficient coverage of large areas
  • No need for gas or electricity, offering an eco-friendly mowing solution
  • Includes a grass catcher for convenient disposal of clippings


  • Manual operation may require more physical effort than powered mowers

Personal Observations:

The Scotts 20-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower stands out for its environmental friendliness, ease of use, and efficient cutting performance.

It offers a clean cut with its 5-blade system, ideal for short grass, and has nine adjustable cutting heights for versatility. Although it struggles with long grass and edges, its maneuverability and lightweight design are pluses.

Maintenance is minimal, involving occasional blade sharpening and lubrication. This mower is a cost-effective, eco-friendly option for small to medium-sized lawns, combining practicality with user comfort and environmental benefits

Best for Tough Grass: Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Earthwise 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Key Features:

  • 7 Blade Ball Bearing Reel: This feature, with a 16-inch cutting width, is particularly efficient for cutting bent grasses like Bermuda, Zoysia, centipede, St. Augustine, and Seashore paspalum. It’s also capable of handling common taller, wetter upright grasses like fescue, bluegrass, and rye grass when used regularly​​.
  • Cutting Height Adjustment: The mower provides a cutting height adjustment range from 1/2 inch to 2 1/2 inches, allowing for flexibility depending on your lawn’s needs​​​​.
  • Lightweight and Easy to Push: Weighing around 26 lbs, it’s designed to be lightweight and easy to maneuver, even by the elderly or those who might find heavier mowers challenging to use​​.
  • Simple Assembly: Assembling the mower is straightforward, typically involving just attaching the handles and setting the cutting height​​.
  • Low Maintenance: This mower is a low-maintenance option, usually requiring only occasional blade sharpening​​.
  • Durable Construction: Made with a durable steel side plate and tempered alloy steel for the reel and bed knife blade, it’s built for long-lasting performance​​​​.
  • Environmental Benefits: Like other push reel mowers, it’s eco-friendly, requiring no gas or oil, producing no emissions, and operating quietly​​.


  • The self-propelled feature of this mower eliminates the challenge of pushing, making it a breeze to cut through even the most stubborn grass.
  • The lack of an engine means no emissions, contributing to a cleaner environment.
  • Equipped with two 4.0Ah batteries and a dual-port charger, I’ve found the mower capable of running longer, minimizing downtime.
  • I’ve personally experienced how well this mower adapts to different grass types, from fine fescue to thick Bermuda, without faltering.
  • The high rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars from customers is a testament to its consistent performance and reliability.


  • At $749.00, the initial investment is steep; however, in my experience, the durability and low maintenance have justified the cost over time.
  • While the lack of an engine is eco-friendly, it may not be suitable for those who prefer a powered option for larger lawns.

Overall Satisfaction:

From my experience, the Earthwise Push Reel Lawn Mower has demonstrated its effectiveness and reliability right from the first use.

Its comfortable handle and ease of control, even on uneven terrain, have greatly reduced the physical effort typically associated with manual mowers.

Over several months, the mower has maintained its durability, showing no wear on the blades or body. Its efficiency in cutting grass cleanly without missing any blades has been notable.

Moreover, the cordless, eco-friendly design aligns perfectly with my sustainable gardening practices, making it a cherished tool in my lawn care routine.

My overall satisfaction with the Earthwise Push Reel Lawn Mower is quite high. It’s an excellent choice for gardeners like me who value a powerful, manual, and environmentally-friendly approach to maintaining a pristine lawn.

Despite its higher price point, the combination of user comfort, cutting efficiency, and positive environmental impact justifies the investment, making it a valuable addition for anyone serious about lawn care.

Best Lightweight: American Lawn Mower Company 14-Inch 4-Blade Mower

American Reel Mower

Key Features:

  • 4-Blade Ball Bearing Reel: It comes with a 4-blade ball bearing reel, ensuring a smooth cutting experience.
  • 14-Inch Cutting Width: The mower has a 14-inch cutting width, which is suitable for small to medium-sized lawns.
  • Durable 8-Inch Polymer Wheels: These wheels enhance maneuverability, making it easier to push the mower across various lawn surfaces.
  • Adjustable Blade Height: The blade height is adjustable between 1 inch and 1.75 inches, giving you flexibility in how you want your grass cut.
  • Scissor-like Cutting Action: This mower cuts grass in a precise scissor-like motion, which is healthier for your grass and provides a better-looking lawn.
  • Heat-Treated Alloy Steel Blades: The mower’s blades are made of heat-treated alloy steel, ensuring durability and longevity.
  • Low Maintenance: It is designed to be low maintenance, only requiring to be sharpened once every 3-5 years.
  • Eco-Friendly and User-Friendly: As a manual push reel mower, it is an eco-friendly alternative to gas-powered lawnmowers and is easy to use without emitting fumes.
  • Lightweight Design: Weighing around 19 pounds, the mower is easy to handle and store, making it ideal for users who may find heavier equipment challenging to use.
  • Suitable for Various Grass Types: The mower is ideal for cool-season grasses like bluegrass, fescue, and rye, providing a clean and precise cut.


  • The eco-friendly aspect of this mower is a true highlight; it emits zero pollutants since it doesn’t require gas or electricity.
  • Weighing only 20 pounds, I found the mower to be exceptionally light, which made it a breeze to push across my yard.
  • Its slim profile isn’t just for show; I could tuck it away in the corner of my garage without it taking up much space.
  • After several months of use, it’s impressive how it continues to deliver a clean cut, even on tougher grass types like Bermuda and St. Augustine.
  • The ergonomic handle design didn’t go unnoticed; my hands didn’t tire as quickly compared to other manual mowers I’ve tried.


  • While the manual operation is a boon for the environmentally conscious, it does require more effort, which mightn’t be ideal for those with large lawns or certain physical conditions.
  • Given that it’s human-powered, tackling a thick, overgrown lawn can be challenging and might necessitate a bit of elbow grease.
  • Although it’s held up well, I did notice that consistent maintenance is key; the blades need regular sharpening to maintain their cutting efficiency.

Personal Insights:

In my experience, the ease of control with American Lawn Mower Company 14-Inch 4-Blade Mower is noteworthy. It turns on a dime, and I’ve been able to navigate around garden beds and trees without issue. Durability-wise, it’s been several seasons, and it’s still going strong.

There’s something satisfying about the quiet snip of the blades as they cut the grass – it’s a stark contrast to the roar of a gas mower.

Overall, I’m very satisfied with this mower’s performance. It’s a solid choice for those who’ve a smaller lawn and place value on environmental sustainability and physical activity.

Best with Grass Catcher: Greenworks RM1400 14-Inch Lawn Mower

Greenworks RM1400

Key Features:

  • 14-Inch Cutting Width: This cutting width is suitable for small to medium-sized lawns, providing a precise and scissor-like cut.
  • 5-Blade Ball Bearing System: This feature ensures smooth navigation and excellent cutting performance, especially for smaller lawns.
  • T-Shaped Handlebars: These handlebars enhance comfort while mowing, making it easier to push and maneuver.
  • Mulching and Bagging Capabilities: The mower provides the option for mulching, which helps restore nutrients to the soil, and it comes with a grass bag for easy clean-up.
  • Height Adjustment: You can adjust the cutting height from 1.06 inches to 2 inches, allowing for versatility depending on your lawn’s condition.
  • Eco-Friendly: Being a manual mower, it is an environmentally friendly option as it does not emit fumes or require fuel.
  • Easy Assembly and Storage: The mower is easy to assemble and lightweight, making it convenient to store. It weighs only 24 pounds and can be hung by the T-shaped handles for space-saving storage.
  • Solid Construction and Durability: It has a sturdy build and requires minimal maintenance.
  • 4-Year Warranty: The mower comes with a generous four-year warranty.
  • Budget-Friendly: It is priced affordably, making it a cost-effective option for lawn care.
  • Best For: Homeowners who want a hassle-free, tidy lawn with an efficient grass catching system.


  • Comes with a prominent brand reputation for reliability and convenience.
  • Free 90-day returns offer peace of mind and risk-free purchasing.
  • Free shipping with the product arriving by January 15.


  • Pickup and delivery options aren’t available for Romulus, 48174.

Personal Observations:

I’ve found the Greenworks RM1400 14-Inch Lawn Mower to be quite suitable for my small to medium-sized lawn.

It’s a push reel mower, meaning I have to manually operate it, but its 14-inch cutting deck and five-blade ball bearing steel reel make for precise, scissor-like cuts. The ergonomic T-shaped handlebars increase comfort and ease of use.

I appreciate the adjustable cutting height between 1.06 and 2 inches, and it’s great that it includes both mulching and bagging capabilities. It’s lightweight at 24 pounds, making it easy for me to assemble and maneuver.

I also like that it requires minimal maintenance, just occasional blade sharpening and lubrication, and the four-year warranty is a bonus.

However, I do find it’s not ideal for larger lawns and sometimes it misses grass at the sides because the blade path doesn’t extend beyond the wheels​.

Best Electric: Scotts 16-Inch 20V Cordless Electric Reel Mower

Scotts 16-Inch 20V Cordless Electric Reel Mower

Key Features:

  • 20-Volt 2.0Ah Battery and Fast Charger: The mower includes a powerful brushless motor powered by a 20-Volt 2.0Ah battery, ensuring sufficient power for lawn mowing tasks. It also comes with a fast charger for quick battery recharge.
  • 16-Inch Cutting Width: It has a wide 16-inch reel, which allows for efficient mowing of your lawn. This width is suitable for small to medium-sized lawns.
  • Grass Catcher Included: The mower comes with a grass catcher, making it easy to collect grass clippings for a cleaner lawn appearance.
  • Dual Operation Mode: You can use this mower with or without the battery, offering flexibility in terms of power use and physical exertion.
  • Comfort and Convenience: The mower is designed with a comfortable foam grip, enhancing ease of use. It also features a detachable handle, which aids in convenient and space-saving storage.
  • Adjustable Blade Height: It allows for height adjustment of the blades, though specific details on the range of height adjustments are not provided.
  • Easy Maneuverability: The mower is equipped with durable polymer wheels, ensuring easy maneuverability across the lawn.
  • Eco-Friendly and Quiet Operation: Being an electric mower, it is quieter compared to gas mowers and environmentally friendly as it does not emit harmful gases.
  • Weight: The mower weighs approximately 37.48 pounds, which is relatively lightweight for an electric mower, facilitating easier handling and movement.
  • Modern Design: It sports a modern lawn mower design, which can be an aesthetic addition to your lawn care tools


  • Cordless design offers unrestricted mobility without the need for a power outlet
  • Quiet operation compared to gas-powered mowers, making it neighborhood-friendly
  • Battery-powered for cleaner energy use, eliminating the need for gas and oil


  • Limited to small and medium-sized lawns due to the 16-inch cutting width

Personal Observations:

I’ve recently been looking into the Scotts 16-Inch 20V Cordless Electric Reel Mower and I’m quite intrigued by what I’ve found. This mower, with its 16-inch reel and powered by a 20-volt battery, seems to offer a great balance between size and power.

The brushless motor is a detail that particularly stands out to me, hinting at efficiency and longevity.

The most appealing aspect, in my opinion, is its dual functionality. Being able to use it both as a cordless electric mower and as a manual reel mower offers flexibility that I find very valuable.

For someone like me, who appreciates both modern convenience and traditional approaches to lawn care, this seems like a perfect fit.

Additionally, the inclusion of a grass catcher bag and a battery charger makes it seem like a comprehensive package for lawn maintenance.

I haven’t had the chance to use this mower myself yet, but its features and design make it a strong contender for my next lawn care purchase.

The thought of maintaining my lawn with such a versatile tool is quite exciting and seems like it would make the chore much more enjoyable.

Also Consider: Great States 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Great States 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Key Features:

  • 18-Inch Cutting Path: It provides a wide cutting path, which makes it effective for mowing small to medium-sized lawns.
  • Adjustable Cutting Height: The mower offers a flexible cutting height range from 0.5 to 2.75 inches, allowing you to adjust the grass height according to your lawn’s needs and seasonal variations.
  • Stainless Steel Bearings and Alloy Steel Blades: The mower is equipped with stainless steel bearings and alloy steel blades that stay sharp, enhancing its durability and cutting efficiency.
  • 10-Inch Diameter Wheels: The large wheels make it easier to maneuver the mower over different terrains, including slightly uneven lawns.
  • Lightweight and Easy to Use: Weighing less than 30 pounds, the mower is easy to push and maneuver. It’s also compact enough for convenient storage, such as hanging on the wall.
  • Low Maintenance and Eco-Friendly: As a manual push mower, it does not require fuel, making it an environmentally friendly option. The mower also requires less frequent sharpening and minimal overall maintenance.
  • Safe and Comfortable to Use: The mower’s design ensures safety as the wheels and blades stop moving when you do. Its loop handle design allows for comfortable use, even during longer mowing sessions.
  • Cost-Effective: This mower is an economical choice, as it does not involve fuel costs or expensive maintenance.


  • Provides a precise, clean cut with its five sharp blades
  • No need for electricity, batteries, or fuel; powered by human effort
  • Lightweight design allows for easy pushing and maneuverability


  • Not suitable for large lawns or overgrown grass

Personal Observations:

I’ve found the Great States 815-18 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower to be an excellent choice for my lawn care. Its light weight, under 30 pounds, makes it easy for me to maneuver and store.

The assembly process is straightforward, and its 18-inch wide cutting reel is efficient for quick mowing.

I particularly like its adjustable cutting height feature, ranging from 0.5 to 2.75 inches, which allows me to adapt to different grass lengths and seasonal changes.

Being a manual mower, it’s eco-friendly, producing no noise or emissions. Maintenance is minimal, mostly just occasional blade sharpening.

However, I do notice it struggles a bit with very long grass and uneven terrain, but overall, it’s a great, environmentally friendly option for maintaining my lawn​

Enhancing Your Lawn Care: Advanced Insights into Selecting the Best Reel Mower

Choosing the perfect reel mower for your lawn is about more than just cutting grass; it’s about enhancing your lawn care experience. With an array of options in the market, it’s crucial to understand the nuanced features that set the best reel mowers apart. 

Performance on Slopes

For mowing on slopes, the Earthwise 1715 reel mower excels with its versatile design. It’s lightweight and ergonomic, featuring a 16-inch cutting width and a seven-blade spider ball bearing reel.

The T-style handle and cushioned grips ensure comfort on uneven terrain, while the 10-inch composite wheels provide smooth movement. Suitable for various types of lawns, this model can cut grass as low as 1/2 inch or as high as 2 1/2 inches​​.

Grass Catching Capabilities

The Greenworks RM1400 reel mower includes a large grass catcher, ideal for those who prefer a clean lawn without extra raking. Its cutting width and dual all-terrain wheels make it easy to maneuver, and the foam grip adds comfort.

Designed for small to medium yards, this mower is practical and efficient, with a foldable handle for easy storage​​.

Ease of Height Adjustment

The Scotts 2000-20 Classic Push Reel Lawn Mower is user-friendly, featuring a QuickSnap height adjuster with 9 positions for cutting heights of 1 to 3 inches.

Its unique rear-wheel design improves maneuverability, and smooth ball bearings ensure efficient blade spinning. The foam grip loop-style handle adds to user comfort during mowing​​.

Cutting Efficiency for Different Grass Types

The Earthwise 1715 and Fiskars 362050-1002 mowers are tailored for specific grass types. The Earthwise 1715’s 7 heat-treated alloy steel blades are ideal for bentgrass, Bermuda, centipede, and Zoysia.

Fiskars 362050-1002, known for its 18-inch InertiaDrive reel, works well for larger yards and various grass types, including St. Augustine and Zoysia. It offers cutting heights from 1 to 4 inches and is effective on uneven terrain​​.

Overall Economic and Environmental Benefits

Reel mowers like Earthwise and Scotts models offer significant economic and environmental advantages. They are cost-effective, with prices ranging from $60-$150, and provide a clean, even cut that protects the lawn.

These mowers yield natural mulch and are safe as they don’t eject debris. They are appealing to eco-conscious homeowners and those who prefer quiet, fuel-free lawn care​​.

What to Consider When Choosing a Reel Mower

When I’m in the market for a reel mower, I consider whether I want the simplicity of a manual model or the ease of a powered one.

I also look at the blades’ quality and the range of cutting heights to ensure it meets my lawn’s needs.

Also Read: How to Use Reel Mower

Manual vs. Powered

Deciding between a manual and powered reel mower hinges on several key factors, including lawn size, terrain, and personal fitness. I’m always mindful of grass health; a manual mower is gentle on the turf and promotes a healthier lawn.

I also consider sharpening frequency. Manual mowers typically require less frequent sharpening compared to their powered counterparts, which is a plus for maintenance.

When it comes to storage solutions, I’ve limited space, so a compact manual mower wins for me. Seasonal usage plays a role too. If I’m only mowing in the growing season, a manual mower suffices.

Lastly, there’s aesthetic preference. I enjoy the quiet and simplicity of a manual mower, making my lawn care routine almost meditative. It’s not just about cutting grass—it’s about my connection to the yard.

Blades and Cutting Height

Reel mower blades

Building on the foundation of choosing between manual and powered reel mowers, it’s crucial to consider the blades and cutting height as they directly affect your lawn’s health and appearance.

The blade material is paramount; high-quality steel blades maintain sharpness longer, reducing sharpening frequency. Dull blades tear grass, inviting disease, so I always look for a model that promises enduring edges.

Additionally, I prefer mowers with easy clipping disposal options to save time and keep my lawn tidy. An ergonomic design ensures I’m comfortable while mowing, which is essential for my larger lawn.

Lastly, I account for seasonal adjustments—being able to change the cutting height helps my grass thrive year-round. These factors are non-negotiable for me when selecting the best reel mower for my garden.

Learn More: Best Blades For Bad Boy Mower [Buying Guide]

Swath Width and Grass Type

Considering the swath width and grass type is crucial, as they determine how efficiently a reel mower can cover your lawn and the quality of the cut. A wider swath means fewer passes, which is great for larger areas.

But it’s not just about size; you’ve got to think about your grass type too. Different grasses have varying optimal grass heights and seasonal growth patterns. A reel mower that’s not up to par with your lawn’s demands won’t do a good job.

And remember, the cutting frequency isn’t a one-size-fits-all deal. It’ll change with moisture levels and terrain slope, too. You don’t want to be stuck mowing every other day because your mower can’t handle the tall or wet grass.

Additional Features

While swath width and grass type are foundational, don’t overlook a reel mower’s additional features that can greatly enhance your mowing experience.

Adjustable handles are a must for me – they help ensure I’m not hunching over, making the task more comfortable and reducing back strain.

Clipping disposal is another key consideration; some mowers have a built-in basket or bag, which saves time on cleanup.

I also pay attention to wheel design, which can affect maneuverability and stability, especially on uneven terrain.

An ergonomic grip is essential for comfort, especially during longer mowing sessions, and it helps me maintain control for better cutting precision.

How We Choose the Best

Selecting the top reel mowers isn’t a task I take lightly; it demands scrutinizing various critical aspects. I’ve assessed each model’s cutting capabilities, user-friendliness, and longevity to ensure you’re investing in quality.

I also look into the latest features and how simple they’re to clean and maintain, so you get the full picture.

Performance Factors

To determine the best reel mowers, we assess multiple performance factors, including ease of use, cutting efficiency, and durability. I delve into cutting precision because a clean cut is vital for lawn health and aesthetics. 

Ease of Use Consideration

I prioritize user-friendliness when choosing the best reel mowers, ensuring they’re not only effective but also straightforward to operate. User comfort is at the top of my list; I look for handles that won’t leave your hands sore after a session of mowing.

Blade sharpness is another crucial factor – a dull blade means more work, so I seek out models that maintain their edge longer, reducing the need for frequent sharpening.

Storage options are also key. I favor reel mowers that fold or compact easily to fit into tight spaces.

Considering mowing frequency, I opt for durability in a mower that can handle regular use without compromise.

Lastly, terrain adaptability is essential; the best reel mowers must glide smoothly over various lawn types, making the chore less of a workout.

Durability and Build Quality

Reel mower

When assessing the best reel mowers for durability and build quality, I focus on the materials and construction that promise longevity and withstand regular use. Material resilience is at the forefront of my evaluation.

I look for high-grade metals and robust plastics that won’t succumb to wear and tear easily. Rust resistance is equally crucial, as outdoor tools are constantly exposed to the elements.

A mower with a protective coating or stainless steel components gets higher marks.

Weight considerations also play a part; a mower shouldn’t be so heavy it’s cumbersome, nor so light it feels flimsy.

I prefer models that strike a balance, offering sturdiness without excessive heft. Assembly ease is a good indicator of thoughtful design, hinting at quality engineering.

Advanced Features and Technology

Selecting the best reel mowers involves scrutinizing the latest advancements in features and technology to ensure users get a cutting-edge lawn care experience. I look for models that exemplify reel precision, ensuring a clean, even cut every time.

Height adjustment features are a must for tackling various grass lengths, and I always check for easy-to-use mechanisms.

Lastly, blade sharpness is non-negotiable. Dull blades tear grass rather than cutting it, so I look for mowers with long-lasting, sharp blades that promise a pristine finish.

Maintenance and Cleaning Efficiency

Beyond the advanced features and sharp blades, the ease of maintenance and cleaning is another critical factor in choosing the best reel mower.

I’m looking for models that simplify blade sharpening, a task that’s essential for a clean cut and the mower’s longevity.

Efficient clipping disposal systems save me time and keep my lawn tidy without extra raking. I also consider storage options; a compact design that’s easy to fold and stow away makes a huge difference in my cramped garage.

Noise Level and Vibration Control

In evaluating reel mowers, I place high importance on low noise output and effective vibration control, as they contribute significantly to a more pleasant lawn care experience.

Quiet operation isn’t just a preference; it’s essential for avoiding disturbances in peaceful neighborhoods. That’s why I look for mowers with noise reduction techniques that keep decibel levels to a minimum.

Additionally, I prioritize models with anti-vibration handles and an ergonomic design, ensuring comfort during use and reducing fatigue.

Smooth mechanics play a critical role too; a mower that glides effortlessly across the lawn minimizes jarring movements and the vibrations that often accompany them.

Price and Value Assessment

Assessing the best reel mowers, I scrutinize not only their price tags but also the overall value they offer to ensure you get the most bang for your buck. It’s about balancing affordability with functionality.

I consider mower aesthetics, understanding that a sleek design can be a joy to use and display. Seasonal usage is key; a mower that’s effective year-round offers greater value.

I look for smart storage solutions that enhance a mower’s worth by making it easy to stow away.

Related: Best Zero Turn Mowers Under 3000 Dollars

Environmental Impact Considerations

Considering the planet’s health, I meticulously analyze each reel mower’s environmental footprint as a critical factor in my reviews.

I’m committed to promoting green initiatives, so I prioritize mowers that contribute to carbon footprints reduction.

I believe it’s essential to choose tools that support wildlife preservation, minimizing disruption to the natural habitats in our gardens.

Soil health is another significant concern; a good reel mower should cut grass cleanly without damaging the earth beneath.

I spotlight models that encourage pollution reduction, not only in terms of air quality but also in noise pollution—an often overlooked environmental stressor.

Customer Support and Warranty Importance

In my quest for the best reel mowers, I also rigorously evaluate the quality of customer support and the robustness of warranty offerings. It’s crucial to know that if you’re investing in a mower, financing options are available and support is just a call away.

A good brand should offer comprehensive repair services and a straightforward process for obtaining replacement parts.

I delve into warranty comparison to ensure you’re protected against defects and wear. The length and terms of a warranty can be a dealbreaker. I also look for companies that provide helpful troubleshooting tips, which can save you time and money.

Ultimately, strong customer support and a solid warranty reflect a company’s confidence in their product and their commitment to your satisfaction.

Our Verdict

My comprehensive look at the best reel mowers on the market, I feel confident in my choices.

From my personal experience, each mower I’ve highlighted stands out for its specific strengths, whether it’s the eco-friendliness of the Fiskars StaySharp or the lightweight convenience of the American Lawn Mower Company’s model.

Balancing factors like lawn size, grass type, and your physical comfort is key. My own lawn has never looked better since switching to a reel mower, and I’ve enjoyed the quiet, environmentally friendly mowing sessions.

So, whether you have a small urban lawn or a more expansive yard, I’m sure you’ll find the perfect fit among these options.

Remember, a great lawn starts with the right tools, and I hope my insights help you achieve that lush, healthy grass you’re aiming for. Happy mowing!

Ethan Dixonete Avatar

Frequently Asked Questions

How do reel mowers perform on lawns with uneven terrain or lots of hills?

I’ve found that reel mowers struggle with uneven terrain due to increased rolling resistance. Slope handling requires more manual effort, and they’re not ideal for long grass or navigating around obstacles.

Can reel mowers be easily repaired or do they require specialized service?

I’ve found reel mowers generally have low maintenance costs and repair frequency. I can often perform DIY repairs, including sharpening techniques, and easily find replacement parts when needed.

Are there attachment options for reel mowers, such as dethatching blades or lawn aerators?

Yes, some reel mowers offer attachment compatibility, including dethatching blades for increased effectiveness and aerator integration. They may also have mulching capabilities and grass collection options to enhance lawn maintenance.

How environmentally friendly are reel mowers compared to electric and gas-powered mowers?

Reel mowers are more environmentally friendly, reducing carbon footprint, noise pollution, and maintenance costs. They also provide physical exercise and are safer for wildlife, unlike their electric and gas-powered counterparts.

Can reel mowers handle wet grass effectively, or should lawns be dry before mowing?

I’ve found that mowing wet grass often leads to clumping and blade jamming. For clean cuts, I’ll wait until the lawn’s dry, especially after morning dew, which also eases mower maintenance.